Pick the poster for Choke.
They are all goddamn amazing. I don't even know which one to choose. "Sex looks like love if you squint"? That's just an awesome tagline. Though they really appear to be playing up the sex aspect, and not playing up the "is he Jesus?" aspect.
If you guys've never read the book, I'd highly recommend it. Just be warned - it's, um, strange. Fight Club is one of Palahniuk's most "normal" books, and the movie is still toned down a great deal. Choke is on the weird end of the spectrum...