Is Andy Pettitte Hall of Fame Material?

In a word, no.

(Oh God it's gonna make me so so so sad when a. Andy retires; b. five or whatever years after he retires, people start writing "hey he should be in the Hall of Fame" articles. Because, unless he sticks around for like three or four more years and he's just out-and-out awesome during those years, he really, really shouldn't. And it breaks my heart to say even slightly bad things about Andy Pettitte.)