So this took me way too long, but I'm bored so I figured better late than never. :)
For photos, please go on Lifetime's Project Runway website. I refer to the order in which they show the photos there.
DANIEL
Overall, I liked his collection. It was mostly BS that he won, but he probably should have been in the top group. I like the way he made sportswear so fashionable, his work had good cohesiveness, and that red carpet look was DIVINE, but he had a few stumbles.
Outfit 1: It's a good sporty look and really, not a whole lot more, unfortunately. His model needs a bra. I like the color scheme; it's vibrant and brings interest to his work.
Outfit 2: This may have been the best of the night, and the look that got him the win (other than the fact that the judges are really biased toward him). It's gorgeous and inventive. I don't know how in tune with Nicole Kidman's style it is, but this dress is really impeccable. While it's a step up from the rest of his collection both in quality and style, it definitely still fits in.
Outfit 3: It's okay. Definitely not anything to rave about, but it's not horrible either. She could look a lot neater, though - this whole thing just reeks of sloppiness - and those pants seem like they have a not-quite-but-almost INSAAAANE crotch (/Michael Kors).
Outfit 4: While it goes along with the rest of his collection, this dress is a pretty big no. I like the blue, but the plastic is just weird and as many others have said, she looks like a suicide bomber or something.
KORTO
She probably would have been my winner. I think this collection is really stunning. She was weirdly bitter on the show, but I can almost understand it. Sure, in her season, Leanne turned out one of the best finale Project Runway collections ever, which justified her not winning then, but here, there's not such an excuse. It's not excessively cohesive, but it definitely goes together. Korto's very good at having things go together subtly.
Outfit 1: It's simple, but Korto does such a great job of working with prints to make kickass dresses that any woman would love to wear. It's just totally adorable. It's perfectly accessorized as well and those shoes are to die for.
Outfit 2: I've never liked those kind of hems, and black is probably too heavy a color to do this dress in, but I love the structured top of the dress and the necklace. Again, the shoes are perfect.
Outfit 3: Freaking adorable. Seriously, I'd buy all of these dresses. This could look really static clingy, but it doesn't at all, because Korto's so talented. I don't love that the shoes are orange, but WHERE CAN I BUY THAT NECKLACE?!
Outfit 4: It's not my style, but it's a great look nevertheless. I love the fabric choice and the shiny... are they shells? are really beautiful and a nice touch to this outfit. Seriously, this was like her weakest look, which says a lot, considering how lovely and stylish it is.
MYCHAEL
Uhhh, it was okay. I think I liked it more than most, but I'm pretty sure I wouldn't put this collection in the top group. I believe it was the rather divine Project Rungay that described his finale collection back in whatever season he was in as "having a very wide range, from hooker on the beach to hooker doing her shopping to very fashionable hooker" or something like that. And, well, his work hasn't lost that. His dresses are cute, but they're always just a skutch too short. Though he's definitely improved from his finale collection... I liked Mychael/Michael, but that was just a mess.
Outfit 1: I think it's cute - I like the structuring details, that seems really sophisticated for him - but yeah, it's just a little too short. I'm not crazy about the shine of the blue or whatever; it looks a little dingy. And what the heck could that bag hold?
Outfit 2: This is really cute, too. Only a model could wear it, due to the way it's got all those non-slimming pleats or whatever going on, but it's cute, and it's definitely not hooker. It's definitely flattering on this girl; it makes a nice silhouette. The neckline is kind of weird, though.
Outfit 3: GREAT color, but it's just too tight to be flattering on anyone - it makes the freakin' model look bulgy - and that belt's kind of a silly throwaway.
Outfit 4: This is definitely my favorite of his dresses, which I think is a pretty unpopular opinion. Yeah, he did just kind of make a super-short, super-tight dress and put some garbage on it, but I think he brought a stylish edge to it. I wouldn't wear this because yeah, it is too short and tight, but it's really cute.
CHRIS
I love Chris March 4-eva, y'all. I agree with his collection being in the top group because it was beautifully made and showed a real evolution, but most of the looks were just too similar to give him a win.
Outfit 1: This is really cute. I hate the shoes, but that's about the only complaint I have. It does strike me as a little Gray Gardens but I think that's because of the head scarf. This looks totally cozy and I'd love it for the fall. The brightness with the tights is nice, too.
Outfit 2: I wish we could see the full legs/feet here for better comparison, but basically the same goes as what I said for Outfit 1. Again, these pieces were too similar and vaguely costume-y (this one is slightly worse with the black headscarf), but that didn't mean they weren't really nice, both fashionable and wearable, and well-made.
Outfit 3: Love that skirt. HATE that top. It's a cute idea, but she looks like she's got Mickey Mouse ears for boobs. But that skirt? I covet it, and the colors are great. I want to buy the skirt just to wear it with those tights and shoes, and a black t-shirt or something.
Outfit 4: Hey Mountaha. I miss Make Me a Supermodel. Anyway, this look is a total miss for me. She looks like she's coming from a drunken one-night stand where she wanted to get out quickly because it turned out the guy was a dog, but she couldn't find her clothes, so she threw on his huge, heavy plaid blanket, and bolted out of there. Oh, and somewhere along the way home she found a ... feather?... and stuck it in the dress. Sorry, that's just what it makes me think of! It's just a terrible idea to make a dress out of a thick plaid fabric. That said, for what it is, it's nicely made.
ULI
Like many have said, this collection was DIVINE. She's definitely developed since the show ended, and the way the judges came down on her for that was gross. She so should have been in the top group and should have been seriously considered for the win. Everything here is gorgeous.
Outfit 1: I'm not crazy about the color and texture or something of the ruffles. It looks a little too much like slashed human flesh. But it's a beautifully made dress and in a different color, it would be great.
Outfit 2: Gorgeous. I wouldn't think it was possible to make a dress in a black khaki color interesting while keeping it simple, but Uli did it. She's a rock star.
Outfit 3: This is probably my least favorite look in her collection, and it's still lovely. The material they used to make the top just looks cheap, and the sideboob doesn't help there. That's really my only complaint. It's really pretty, flattering, and interesting.
Outfit 4: STUNNING. That's really all I have to say. I love the structure of this and how it's so busy while still being beautiful. This girl was robbed.
JEFFREY
No, just no.
Outfit 1: I like the top, and I like the zipper belt. It definitely has a dark romantic thing going on, which is nice. I'm kind of fishing for compliments here, because I think it's terrible. She just looks sloppy, the thing around the neck is a mess, and The Fucking Shoes.
Outfit 2: There is not a single thing that is okay with this.
Outfit 3: I was thinking about what to write for this one for a good two minutes. After thinking about it, I had one sentence in my head, and it may be non-sensical, but to me, it sums up this outfit perfectly. It would be nice, if it wasn't so terrible. In the chosen picture, even the model looks like "ugh, seriously?"
Outfit 4: Definitely the best of the collection and actually a pretty good dress. I love the color combination and I'm a big sucker for sequins. Heck, between the black and the sequins and the shortness/tightness, it's very Heidi Klum. Added bonus for not pairing this with The Worst Shoes Ever. It's weirdly lumpy, but I really do like this dress.
SANTINO
Again, no, just no. I can't decide who was worse, Jeffrey or Santino.
Outfit 1: Trashy. It's effectively a silver condom. I like his model's hair, though.
Outfit 2: You know what? This is kind of cute. I know people who would totally wear this. I might wear something like this, on a particularly lazy day. It's almost a little like a Christian Siriano design. Are the leggings sparkly, or just a weird fabric? If they're sparkly, I love them forever. That said, the shirt just looks sloppy and the black bows are messy and out of place.
Outfit 3: HELL TO THE NO.
Outfit 4: I hate the chain, and this looks like an ice skating outfit, but it's actually okay. Or maybe Santino was a genius and put a merely okay outfit after a total disgrace, so that we'd think the okay outfit was better than it really was. I don't like how the leggings are bunching and what the hell was Nicole Kidman going to wear in this collection?
SWEET P
I liked her on the show, but I thought this collection was terrible. Why the HELL was she in the top group? I know many people were offended by Daniel being there, but IMO this was worse.
Outfit 1: It's the best outfit of her collection and it's still only okay. I like those kind of shoulder/neck lines, but I don't like the frilly stuff she has going on at the sleeve. The color is kind of dingy and blah. But it's cute.
Outfit 2: Ugly ugly ugly. It looks like she's wearing a sack. It does nothing for her. The ribbon's just kind of plopped on.
Outfit 3: DIVINE GODDESS ANYA!!!!!! I feel bad for her, having to wear this shit. It doesn't fit, it's ugly, the colors are hideous, and it's far too literal. Nothing will beat Santino's silver body suit horror show and Jeffrey's second outfit was almost as bad, but this was definitely the third worst of the night. Gross.
Outfit 4: SHANNON!!!! This could have been so cute, but I don't really like it at all as is. It just looks so dingy and droopy, like flowers left out to dry way too long.
RANKING TIME
From best to worst.
Korto
Uli
Chris
Daniel
Mychael
Sweet P
Jeffrey
Santino
Top two are divine, #3 is great, 4 and 5 are solid, the last three are total embarrassments.
